Shekinah Haitian Seventh-day Adventist Church
← Back to Blog Bible Answers

Who Decided Which Books Are in the Bible? How the Canon Was Formed

By · · 18 min read

No emperor or single council picked the books of the Bible; here is how God's people recognized the Old and New Testament over time, and why the 66 books can be trusted.

Picture a quiet evening at the kitchen table. A teenager scrolls through a short video that claims the Bible was assembled long after Jesus by powerful men who kept the books they liked and quietly buried the others. The teenager looks up and asks a fair question: who decided which books are in the Bible, and how do we know they got it right? It is a question many Christians have never been taught to answer, and it deserves a patient, honest reply.

The question is not a sign of weak faith. It is the kind of question careful readers have asked for centuries, and the early church asked it too. When you trace the history slowly, using the actual letters, lists, and council records that survive, a very different picture appears from the one in viral videos. Instead of a few powerful people making a choice behind closed doors, you find generations of believers recognizing the books that were already feeding the church.

This article walks through that story in plain language. We will look at how the Hebrew Scriptures were received, how the New Testament books came to be gathered, what the famous lists and councils actually said, why Constantine did not choose the books, and why many Christians trust the 66 books found in most Protestant Bibles today. Along the way we will be clear about what the Bible itself says and where we are offering an interpretation of the history.

The short answer

No single person or council decided which books are in the Bible. The Hebrew Scriptures were received by the Jewish people long before Jesus, and He treated them as Scripture. The New Testament books were written in the first century and recognized gradually by churches that read them, so later lists and councils mostly confirmed what believers already used.

39Old Testament books
27New Testament books
367 ADFirst list of the 27

That is the heart of it, but the details matter, because the details are exactly where the myths grow. The church did not create the authority of these books. Christians believe God gave that authority when He inspired them, and the church's task was to recognize it, protect it, and pass it on faithfully.

What does the Bible say about its own authority?

The Bible teaches that its authority comes from God, not from a vote. That is the starting point for everything else in this article. Paul wrote to Timothy that the Scriptures Timothy had known since childhood were able to make him wise unto salvation, and then he added a sentence that every discussion of the canon has to begin with.

"All scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness: That the man of God may be perfect, thoroughly furnished unto all good works." 2 Timothy 3:16 to 17, KJV

Notice the order in that verse. Scripture is first given by inspiration of God, and only then is it profitable for teaching and correction. The church receives a word it did not author. This is why many Christians speak of the canon as something discovered and recognized rather than invented, and it is why the question of who chose the books of the Bible is really a question about who listened carefully enough to recognize what God had already given.

The statement of faith that guides this church puts it this way: the Holy Scriptures, Old and New Testaments, are the written Word of God, given by divine inspiration, and they are the supreme, authoritative, and the infallible revelation of His will. That is a confession of faith, not a historical argument, but it shapes how we read the history. If God inspired these books, we would expect His people to notice their voice over time, even when the process looked slow and human from the outside.

How was the Bible canon formed for the Old Testament?

The Old Testament was received by the Jewish people as their sacred writings well before the time of Jesus. Paul wrote in Romans 3:2 that "unto them were committed the oracles of God," which means the Jewish community was the first guardian of the Hebrew Scriptures. Christians did not have to build an Old Testament from nothing, because they inherited one.

Jesus Himself pointed to the familiar shape of those Scriptures. He never questioned which books belonged to the Word of God, and He quoted them as settled authority. After His resurrection, He told His disciples that everything written about Him had to be fulfilled.

"And he said unto them, These are the words which I spake unto you, while I was yet with you, that all things must be fulfilled, which were written in the law of Moses, and in the prophets, and in the psalms, concerning me." Luke 24:44, KJV

The law, the prophets, and the psalms match the three part structure of the Hebrew Bible that Jewish readers still use: the Torah, the Prophets, and the Writings, where Psalms stands near the front of the Writings. Encyclopaedia Britannica explains that the Hebrew Bible is called the Tanakh, a name built from those three divisions, and that it is traditionally counted as 24 books. Those 24 are the same writings Protestant Bibles divide into 39, because books like Samuel, Kings, and the twelve Minor Prophets are counted differently. The content is the same even when the numbering looks different.

Did a Jewish council at Jamnia decide the Hebrew Bible?

A Jewish gathering at Jamnia did not invent the Hebrew Bible, though it is often described that way. Britannica notes that rabbis at Jabneh, also called Jamnia, around 90 or 100 AD settled the place of a few books whose status had been doubted, such as the Song of Songs and Ecclesiastes. The Tyndale House scholar Tony Watkins writes that the Hebrew canon seems to have been well established by the second century before Christ, with some debate about the Writings continuing into the first century AD. In other words, the rabbis were talking about books already in use, not assembling a new collection from scratch.

Pages of an old handwritten book resting open, a reminder of how carefully Scripture was copied by hand

When was the Bible put together for the New Testament?

The New Testament books were written in the first century, and churches began reading them as Scripture almost immediately, but the complete list of 27 books was not written down in one place until 367 AD. That gap of about three centuries is what confuses many people. It sounds like a long time, until you remember that every copy was made by hand, that churches were spread across the Roman world, and that Christians faced waves of persecution that made gathering and comparing writings difficult.

Even within the New Testament itself, you can see the process starting. The apostles knew they were writing with authority, and their readers noticed it. Peter wrote about the letters of Paul and placed them alongside the older Scriptures.

"As also in all his epistles, speaking in them of these things; in which are some things hard to be understood, which they that are unlearned and unstable wrest, as they do also the other scriptures, unto their own destruction." 2 Peter 3:16, KJV

The phrase "the other scriptures" is striking. Within the apostolic generation, Paul's letters were already being treated as belonging with the sacred writings. Watkins notes that the four Gospels were treated as Scripture right from the beginning and that by the second century Christians accepted Paul's letters as carrying divine authority. The center of the New Testament was never really in doubt.

Which New Testament books took longer to be accepted?

A handful of shorter books took longer to be accepted everywhere, and early Christian writers discussed those doubts openly. The church historian Eusebius, writing in the early 300s, sorted books into groups in his Church History, book 3, chapter 25. He listed the four Gospels, Acts, the letters of Paul, 1 John, and 1 Peter as accepted by all, and he called James, Jude, 2 Peter, and 2 and 3 John disputed but "nevertheless recognized by many." Revelation he described with some hesitation, because some churches accepted it and others did not yet.

Eusebius also named writings that were rejected, including the Shepherd of Hermas, the Epistle of Barnabas, and the Apocalypse of Peter, and he said that gospels carrying the names of Peter, Thomas, and Matthias should be cast aside. That detail matters for anyone who has heard that the church hid other gospels. Those books were known, discussed openly, and set aside because they did not carry the marks of apostolic teaching.

Centuries before Christ
Hebrew Scriptures receivedThe law, the prophets, and the writings preserved by the Jewish people
First century AD
New Testament writtenLetters of Paul, the Gospels, and the other apostolic writings circulate among churches
About 200 AD
Muratorian FragmentOldest surviving list of New Testament books, read at Rome
Early 300s
Eusebius, Church History 3.25Sorts books into accepted, disputed, and rejected
325 AD
Council of NicaeaOften blamed for the canon, but it did not vote on the books
367 AD
Athanasius, Festal Letter 39First list naming exactly the 27 New Testament books
393 and 397 AD
Councils of Hippo and CarthageRegional councils in North Africa confirm the same New Testament list

What did the early lists and councils actually say?

The early lists show a church slowly writing down what it already read, not a committee voting books in or out. Each list is a window into a particular place and time. Looking at the main documents one at a time makes this clear, and it also helps you answer friends who repeat claims they heard online.

What is the Muratorian Fragment?

The Muratorian Fragment is the oldest surviving list of New Testament writings, a Latin document that Britannica dates to about 200 AD and describes as reflecting the books read at Rome. Scholars still debate its exact date, and Watkins notes that it was written sometime between about 170 AD and the fourth century. Britannica points out that Hebrews and 1 Peter do not appear in it, while a short letter like Jude does. It is a snapshot of one church at one moment, and it shows a collection that was already mostly formed.

What did Athanasius write in his Festal Letter 39?

Athanasius, bishop of Alexandria, wrote an Easter letter to his churches in 367 AD that lists exactly the 27 books of our New Testament. Britannica says that this New Testament canon appears for the first time in his 39th Festal Letter. After naming the books, Athanasius wrote, in the translation by R. Payne Smith published in the Nicene and Post Nicene Fathers series, "These are fountains of salvation, that they who thirst may be satisfied with the living words they contain." He then added, "Let no man add to these, neither let him take ought from these."

Athanasius was honest about the edges of his list too. He named some other books that were "not indeed included in the Canon, but appointed by the Fathers to be read by those who newly join us," including the Wisdom of Solomon, Sirach, Judith, Tobit, the Teaching of the Apostles, and the Shepherd. He left Esther out of his Old Testament list and named it in that group as well, even though Esther belongs to the Hebrew Bible. He counted 22 Old Testament books because, as he put it, that number was handed down as the number of the letters among the Hebrews. That candor is reassuring, because it shows a pastor sorting books by their history and use, not a ruler inventing a collection.

What did the councils of Hippo and Carthage decide?

The councils of Hippo in 393 and Carthage in 397 were regional meetings of bishops in North Africa, and they confirmed the same 27 book New Testament that Athanasius had listed. Britannica notes that a Roman synod under Bishop Damasus in 382 had already adopted a matching list and that synods in Africa, under the leadership of Augustine, confirmed the same list for their province. The Carthage text begins with the rule that "besides the Canonical Scriptures nothing be read in the Church under the title of divine Scriptures," which shows that the concern was what could be read aloud in worship.

The historian Philip Schaff, writing in his History of the Christian Church, observed that by the time of these councils the whole church "must have already become nearly unanimous" on the New Testament, so that there seemed to be no need even for a general council to approve it. That is an important point, and it matches the way Athanasius had already written about these books thirty years earlier. The councils did not hand down a new list from above. They wrote down a settled agreement so that local churches would stop reading doubtful books in worship.

SourceDateWhat it shows
Muratorian FragmentAbout 200 ADMost New Testament books already read at Rome
Eusebius, Church History 3.25Early 300sCore books accepted everywhere, five short letters still debated
Athanasius, Festal Letter 39367 ADExactly the 27 New Testament books listed
Synod at Rome under Damasus382 ADSame list adopted in the West
Councils of Hippo and Carthage393 and 397 ADSame list confirmed for North Africa

Did Constantine write the Bible?

No, Constantine did not write the Bible, and he did not choose its books. The New Testament books were being read in the churches long before he was born, as the Muratorian Fragment from about 200 AD already shows. The Council of Nicaea, which he called in 325 AD, is often blamed for the canon, but it met over other questions, and a separate article on this site tells that story in full. Here we will look at one detail that is often left out.

What Constantine did do is often twisted into the myth. Eusebius records in his Life of Constantine, book 4, chapter 36, that the emperor wrote asking him to "order fifty copies of the sacred Scriptures" written by skilled scribes for the growing churches in his new capital. Ordering copies of books the churches were already reading is very different from deciding what those books should be. Copying a collection is not the same as creating one, and the evidence from before and after Constantine shows the same core New Testament books in use.

KEEP READINGDid Constantine Really Change the Bible? The Truth About the Council of Nicaea (325 AD)
Old manuscripts and bound books stacked on a wooden shelf, the kind of handmade copies that carried Scripture through the centuries

Who chose the books of the Bible, and what tests did the early church use?

The early church did not choose the books by popularity but by asking whether each writing carried the authority of the apostles and agreed with the faith already received. Watkins points to several marks in his article for Tyndale House: whether a text was written by an apostle or someone very closely associated with the apostles, whether its contents were in line with the apostles' teaching, and whether church leaders cited it widely as Scripture. He also stresses that the books were not chosen because early Christians simply liked them.

These tests help explain why books like the Gospel of Thomas were left out. Eusebius placed it among the writings to be cast aside as absurd and impious, because its style was at variance with apostolic usage and its thoughts were out of accord with true orthodoxy, and because no church writer of the earlier generations had thought it worthy of mention. The same tests also explain why Hebrews, James, and Revelation took a little longer. Britannica notes that Hebrews was accepted in the East but disputed in the West, that James was doubted by even more writers, and that Revelation faced more opposition than any other book finally received. Over time, as the churches compared their traditions, those doubts gave way.

Here we move from history to interpretation, so it is fair to say it plainly. Christians who hold to Scripture alone believe the Holy Spirit guided this slow process, so that God's people recognized the books He had inspired. Jesus said, "My sheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow me" (John 10:27, KJV), and many believers see the canon as an example of that promise on a grand scale. The historical record cannot prove the work of the Spirit, but it is fully consistent with it.

Why do Catholic and Orthodox Bibles have more books?

Catholic and Orthodox Bibles include several books in their Old Testament, often called the deuterocanonical books, that are not part of the Hebrew Bible. Britannica lists Tobit, Judith, Wisdom, Ecclesiasticus (also called Sirach), Baruch, and 1 and 2 Maccabees in the Roman Catholic canon. Many of these books were included in the Septuagint, the Greek translation of the Hebrew Scriptures that many early Christians read, as Britannica explains. The Council of Carthage in 397 included Tobit, Judith, and two books of Maccabees in its list.

Our Catholic and Orthodox neighbors value these books sincerely, and their reasons deserve respect. Britannica explains that the Council of Trent, which met from 1545 to 1563, made the larger canon including the deuterocanonical books the official list for Roman Catholics, and Watkins dates that decision to 1546. The Eastern Orthodox churches, according to Britannica, set their Old Testament canon at the Synod of Jerusalem in 1672, accepting Tobit, Judith, Wisdom, and Ecclesiasticus, so their list differs slightly from the Catholic one. For Catholic and Orthodox Christians these books are fully part of Scripture, and many other readers also value them for their history and devotion.

Protestant Bibles follow a different path, and this is where the reasoning matters most. Britannica notes that the Reformers did not accept these books as Scripture, and that Martin Luther's translation of the Bible placed them in a separate section called the Apocrypha, books worth reading but not on the same level as canonical Scripture. Several reasons support the 66 book canon, beginning with the fact that these books were not part of the Hebrew Bible that the Jewish people received and Jesus affirmed. Watkins observes that there is very little evidence that any major Jewish group accepted them. And even Athanasius, in the fourth century, placed several of them among books to be read for instruction rather than inside the canon.

Where does the book of Enoch fit?

The book of Enoch sits outside both the Protestant and the Catholic Bible. It is an ancient Jewish writing that was known in the early church, yet it was not part of the Hebrew Scriptures and it was not received as Scripture by most churches. Its story connects with the Dead Sea Scrolls and with the short letter of Jude, and this article explains that history in detail.

KEEP READINGWhy Is the Book of Enoch Missing from the Bible? Dead Sea Scrolls & Canon History

Why can we trust the 66 books today?

We can trust the 66 books because the Old Testament matches the Scriptures Jesus used and affirmed, and the New Testament matches the apostolic writings that the churches recognized everywhere over time. The history shows a careful, public process with real disagreements discussed openly, not a secret decision. Books that were debated were debated in writing, by people whose letters we can still read, and the core of the collection was never in question.

There is also a deeper reason, one that rests on faith rather than on history alone. Isaiah wrote, "The grass withereth, the flower fadeth: but the word of our God shall stand for ever" (Isaiah 40:8, KJV). Christians believe that the God who spoke through the prophets and apostles also cared enough to preserve His word for every generation. When we read the 66 books, we find one consistent story of creation, fall, promise, and redemption through Jesus Christ, from Genesis to Revelation. That unity across many authors and many centuries is itself a quiet testimony that one Author stands behind it.

This is why Christians who hold to Scripture alone see it as the rule for faith. If the authority of the Bible came from a church council, then the council would stand above the Bible. But if the authority comes from God, then councils, pastors, and every one of us stand under it, listening and learning. The early bishops who wrote those lists seem to have understood that, which is why Athanasius warned that no one should add to the books or take from them.

How can you answer this question with confidence in everyday life?

You can answer this question calmly by learning a few key facts and then pointing people to the original sources, because the history is open for anyone to read. Many of the early letters and council records are available online in English translations. When a friend or family member repeats a claim from a video, you do not need to argue. You can simply invite them to look at what Athanasius, Eusebius, and the councils actually wrote.

STEP 1Learn the short answerRemember that the books were recognized over time, not chosen by one person
STEP 2Know three dates325 for Nicaea, 367 for Athanasius, 393 and 397 for Hippo and Carthage
STEP 3Read a source yourselfOpen Festal Letter 39 and read the list in Athanasius's own words
STEP 4Ask a gentle questionAsk where the claim came from and whether it cites any early document
STEP 5Return to the textSpend more time reading Scripture than reading about it

Parents can turn this into a family conversation. Read Luke 24:44 together and talk about why Jesus named the law, the prophets, and the psalms. Then read 2 Peter 3:16 and notice how Peter called Paul's letters Scripture. Children and teenagers often find it encouraging to discover that the Bible's own pages show the canon forming, and that their questions have honest answers.

Questions people ask

Did the Catholic Church decide which books are in the Bible?

The Catholic Church did not create the authority of the Bible's books, though early church councils, which the Catholic Church counts as part of its own history, did write down official lists. The New Testament books were already being read across the churches before any council met, and regional synods at Rome, Hippo, and Carthage in the late 300s confirmed a list that churches already widely accepted. Catholics understand the church's role somewhat differently from Protestants, seeing these decisions as authoritative, while Protestants see them as faithful recognition of what God had given.

Were other gospels removed from the Bible?

Other gospels were never part of the Bible, so they were not removed from it. Writings like the Gospel of Thomas or the Gospel of Peter were known in the early church, and writers such as Eusebius discussed them openly and explained why they were not accepted. They did not match the teaching of the four Gospels that the churches had read since the first century.

Is the Bible canon closed, or could new books be added?

Christians who hold to Scripture alone believe the canon is closed. The books came through the prophets and apostles God chose, and that written foundation was complete with the apostolic generation. A newly discovered ancient letter, even a genuine one, would be a historical treasure but not new Scripture. Many of these Christians also believe the Holy Spirit still gives spiritual gifts today, including prophecy, yet no later message is ever added to the Bible. Any such message must agree with Scripture and be tested by it, because the Bible remains the standard by which all teaching and experience must be tested.

Why does Athanasius list 22 Old Testament books instead of 39?

Athanasius counted 22 Old Testament books because he had received a tradition that matched the number of books to the 22 letters of the Hebrew alphabet. In his count, the first and second books of Chronicles were one book, Samuel and Kings were counted as two books in place of four, and the twelve Minor Prophets were one book. His list is very close to the Hebrew Scriptures, though he joined Baruch and a letter to the book of Jeremiah and placed Esther among the books to be read.

Reflection questions

When you hear a bold claim about the Bible online, what is your first reaction, and how could you respond with both confidence and kindness? How does it change your reading of Scripture to know that God's people recognized these books over many generations rather than one person choosing them? Which book of the Bible have you read the least, and what might God want to say to you through it this week?

A word of encouragement

You do not need a history degree to trust your Bible. The story of how these books came together is not a secret that crumbles under examination. It is a story of ordinary believers, faithful copyists, and careful pastors who listened for God's voice and held on to what they heard. The same Spirit who guided them is willing to guide you as you open the pages and read.

If questions about the Bible have unsettled you, take heart. Honest questions often lead to deeper faith, because they push us back to the source. The Bible has been examined by friends and critics for two thousand years, and it still speaks with power to the heart that seeks God.

A prayer

Father in heaven, thank You for speaking through the prophets and apostles and for preserving Your word for us. Thank You for the believers who copied, read, and protected these books through hard centuries. When doubts come, give us patience to look for the truth and humility to listen to Your voice in Scripture. Help us not only to know where the Bible came from, but to love the Savior it reveals. In the name of Jesus we pray, amen.

Your next step

If this question has stirred a desire to understand the Bible more deeply, a free Bible study is a simple and welcoming place to begin. You can study at your own pace, ask the questions you have been carrying, and discover how the whole Bible points to Jesus. There is no pressure and no cost, only an open invitation to read God's word with someone who cares.

KEEP READINGStart a Free Bible Study

We would also love to welcome you in person at Shekinah church in Alvarado, Texas. Sabbath School begins Saturday at 10:00 AM and the Divine Service follows at 11:30 AM, with worship in Kreyòl, French, and English, and the church family shares a meal together after the service. If you cannot come in person yet, you can join our prayer meeting on Zoom every Tuesday and Wednesday at 7:30 PM or watch worship live on YouTube.

"All scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness:" 2 Timothy 3:16, KJV
FREE NEWSLETTER

Get new Bible answers and encouragement in your inbox

Hope for hard days, Bible answers, help for your family, and church news from Shekinah, twice a month. No spam, and you can unsubscribe anytime.